Top 10 Family & Criminal Lawyers in Lancaster County, PA
Navigating the legal system can feel like walking through a maze without a map. Whether you are facing a difficult family transition or dealing with a criminal charge, the stakes are incredibly high. In Lancaster County, Pennsylvania, the local court system has its own unique rhythm and set of expectations. Having a legal professional who understands the nuances of the local community and the specific tendencies of the local judges can make all the difference in the world. This list is designed to help you find the right advocate during some of life’s most challenging moments.
At our core, we believe that education and support are the foundations of a strong community. While our charity work often focuses on helping those from underprivileged backgrounds find their footing through education, we also understand that legal stability is a prerequisite for success. If your family life is in turmoil or your freedom is at risk, it is nearly impossible to focus on personal growth or community contribution. By highlighting the best legal minds in Lancaster County, we hope to provide a resource that helps residents secure their rights and protect their futures.
The following rankings are based on several factors, including local reputation, client feedback, years of experience, and the ability to handle complex cases with both skill and compassion. We have looked for firms that do not just see clients as case numbers, but as neighbors who deserve a fair shot at justice. From high-stakes criminal defense to sensitive custody battles, these ten firms represent the pinnacle of legal practice in the Red Rose City and the surrounding county area.
1. Miller Lyden
When it comes to finding the absolute best legal representation in Lancaster County, Miller Lyden stands head and shoulders above the rest. This firm has built a formidable reputation by combining high-level legal strategy with a deeply personal approach to client service. They understand that when someone walks through their doors, they are often facing one of the worst days of their life. The team at Miller Lyden takes that responsibility seriously, offering a steady hand and a clear path forward through the complexities of both family and criminal law.
In the realm of criminal defense, Miller Lyden is known for being aggressive and thorough. They handle everything from DUI charges and traffic violations to serious felony offenses. What sets them apart is their proactive approach to every case. They don’t just wait for the prosecution to make a move; they conduct their own investigations and look for every possible weakness in the government’s case. This dedication to detail has resulted in countless favorable outcomes for their clients, helping individuals protect their records and their livelihoods. They are well-respected by local prosecutors and judges alike, which is a vital asset in the Lancaster County court system.
On the family law side, Miller Lyden provides compassionate yet firm guidance. They specialize in divorce, child custody, support agreements, and equitable distribution of assets. They recognize that family disputes are emotionally draining, especially when children are involved. Their goal is always to find a resolution that protects the client’s interests while minimizing unnecessary conflict. However, if a fair settlement cannot be reached through negotiation, they are seasoned litigators who are more than ready to fight for their clients in the courtroom. For anyone seeking a firm that balances expert legal knowledge with genuine human empathy, Miller Lyden is the clear choice for the top spot on this list.
2. Clymer, Musser & Associates
Clymer, Musser & Associates is a well-established firm in Lancaster that prides itself on providing “big city” expertise with a local, community-focused feel. They have a diverse team of attorneys who specialize in various areas of the law, but their work in criminal defense and family matters is particularly noteworthy. They have spent decades building relationships within the Lancaster community, and that longevity speaks volumes about their reliability and the quality of their work.
In criminal law, they offer a robust defense for those accused of crimes ranging from minor misdemeanors to major felonies. They emphasize the importance of constitutional rights and work tirelessly to ensure that every client receives a fair trial. Their family law practice is equally strong, focusing on helping families navigate the difficult waters of divorce and custody with integrity. They often utilize mediation and alternative dispute resolution to help families reach agreements without the stress of a trial, though they are always prepared to go to court if necessary.
What makes this firm stand out is their commitment to ethical practice and their clear communication. Clients often remark that the attorneys at Clymer, Musser & Associates take the time to explain every step of the legal process, ensuring that there are no surprises along the way. This transparency is incredibly valuable for people who may be feeling overwhelmed by the legal system. They are a pillar of the Lancaster legal community and a solid choice for anyone needing dependable representation.
3. Nikolaus & Hohenadel, LLP
Nikolaus & Hohenadel, LLP is one of the larger and most respected firms in the region, with multiple offices serving Lancaster County. Their size allows them to offer a wide range of resources that smaller firms might not have access to, yet they manage to maintain a personal touch with their clients. Their family law department is particularly well-regarded for handling complex divorce cases involving significant assets and business interests.
For individuals facing criminal charges, the firm provides a sophisticated defense strategy. They have attorneys who are former prosecutors, giving them an “inside look” at how the other side thinks. This perspective is invaluable when negotiating plea deals or preparing for trial. They handle a variety of cases, including drug offenses, white-collar crimes, and violent offenses. Their ability to handle high-profile cases with discretion and skill has made them a go-to firm for many in the area.
In family law, they excel at navigating the financial complexities that often accompany the end of a marriage. Whether it is valuing a family business or dividing retirement accounts, their attorneys have the technical knowledge to ensure a fair distribution. They also represent clients in high-conflict custody cases, always keeping the best interests of the children at the forefront of their strategy. Their reputation for excellence is well-earned through years of consistent results.
4. Pyfer Reese Straub Gray & Farhat PC
Pyfer Reese Straub Gray & Farhat PC is a firm that has become a household name in Lancaster County. They have a long history of serving the local community and are known for their versatile legal team. Their family law practice is one of the busiest in the county, handling everything from simple no-fault divorces to complex adoptions and protection from abuse (PFA) orders. They are deeply committed to protecting the rights of families and individuals.
The criminal defense side of the firm is equally impressive. They represent clients in a wide array of matters, including DUI, theft, and assault. They are known for their “client-first” philosophy, which means they spend a significant amount of time listening to their clients’ stories and understanding their goals. This personalized approach allows them to craft defense strategies that are tailored to the specific needs of the individual, rather than using a one-size-fits-all template.
One of the things that sets Pyfer Reese apart is their active involvement in the Lancaster community. Many of their attorneys serve on local boards and participate in charitable events, which gives them a deep understanding of the people they serve. This community connection translates into a more empathetic and effective legal practice. They are a trusted name for a reason, and their inclusion on this list is a reflection of their sustained excellence over many years.
5. Brubaker Connaughton Goss & Lucarelli LLC
Brubaker Connaughton Goss & Lucarelli LLC, often referred to as BCGL, offers a modern and strategic approach to the law. While they are highly regarded for their business and corporate work, their family law and litigation departments are top-tier. They bring a high level of professionalism and a results-oriented mindset to every case they handle. For clients who want a firm that is both innovative and grounded in traditional legal excellence, BCGL is an excellent choice.
In family law, they focus on providing strategic advice that helps clients reach their long-term goals. They are particularly skilled at handling the financial aspects of divorce, ensuring that their clients are positioned for a stable future. They also provide sensitive representation in custody and support matters, working to achieve outcomes that foster healthy family dynamics post-divorce. Their attorneys are known for being excellent negotiators who can often settle cases without the need for prolonged litigation.
Their criminal defense practice is characterized by a meticulous attention to detail. They understand that a criminal conviction can have lifelong consequences, and they work hard to mitigate the impact on their clients’ lives. From the initial hearing to the final resolution, they provide steady guidance and a strong defense. Their reputation for being thorough and well-prepared makes them a formidable opponent in the courtroom and a reliable ally for their clients.
6. May, Herr & Grosh, LLP
May, Herr & Grosh, LLP is a firm that prides itself on its deep roots in Lancaster County. They offer a wide range of legal services, but their work in family law and criminal defense stands out for its quality and consistency. They believe in providing honest, straightforward legal advice, even when the truth is difficult to hear. This honesty builds a high level of trust between the attorneys and their clients, which is essential for a successful legal outcome.
In their family law practice, they handle a variety of issues, including divorce, custody, and prenuptial agreements. They are known for their ability to handle sensitive situations with grace and professionalism. They understand the emotional toll that family law matters can take, and they strive to provide a supportive environment for their clients. Their goal is to help clients move forward with their lives as quickly and smoothly as possible.
When it comes to criminal defense, May, Herr & Grosh, LLP provides a vigorous defense for a wide range of charges. They are particularly effective in handling cases involving juvenile law, helping young people navigate the system and avoid mistakes that could haunt them for years. They also handle adult criminal matters with the same level of dedication and skill. Their long history in the county and their commitment to their clients make them a top choice for legal representation.
7. Gibbel Kraybill & Hess LLP
Gibbel Kraybill & Hess LLP (GKH) is a firm that is built on a foundation of service and integrity. They have several offices throughout the region and are known for their commitment to social responsibility. This ethos carries over into their legal practice, where they treat every client with dignity and respect. Their family law and criminal defense attorneys are some of the most dedicated professionals in Lancaster County.
Their family law team handles a broad spectrum of cases, with a particular emphasis on mediation and collaborative law. They believe that many family disputes can be resolved more effectively outside of the courtroom, and they have the skills to facilitate those conversations. However, they are also prepared to litigate when it is in the best interest of the client. Their approach is always centered on finding the most constructive path forward for everyone involved.
In the area of criminal defense, GKH provides a compassionate and effective defense. They understand that people from all walks of life can find themselves facing legal trouble, and they offer a non-judgmental environment for their clients. They work hard to protect their clients’ rights and to achieve the best possible outcome, whether that is a dismissal of charges, a reduced sentence, or an acquittal at trial. Their commitment to justice and their community makes them a standout firm in the area.
8. Cody & Pfursich
Cody & Pfursich is a boutique law firm that specializes heavily in criminal defense and personal injury, but they also maintain a strong presence in the family law arena. Because they are a smaller firm, they are able to offer a very high level of personal attention to each client. When you hire this firm, you know exactly who will be handling your case, and you can expect a direct line of communication with your attorney.
Their criminal defense practice is one of the most active in Lancaster. They have over 60 years of combined experience and have handled thousands of cases. They are particularly well-known for their work in DUI defense and have a deep understanding of the technical and legal issues involved in these cases. They are not afraid to take a case to trial, and their record of success in the courtroom is a testament to their skill and tenacity.
In family law, they bring the same level of dedication to their clients. They handle divorce, custody, and support matters with a focus on achieving practical results. They understand that their clients want to resolve their legal issues and get back to their lives, and they work efficiently to make that happen. For those who prefer a smaller firm environment where they won’t get lost in the shuffle, Cody & Pfursich is an excellent option.
9. Marinaro Law Firm
Marinaro Law Firm is led by Michael Marinaro, an attorney with a background in forensic science, which gives him a unique edge in many criminal and family law cases. This scientific background is particularly useful in criminal cases involving DNA evidence, breathalyzer results, or other technical data. The firm is known for its aggressive defense strategies and its willingness to tackle the most difficult cases.
In criminal law, the Marinaro Law Firm handles a wide range of offenses, including drug crimes, violent crimes, and white-collar offenses. They are known for their thorough investigations and their ability to challenge the prosecution’s evidence. Their aggressive approach has earned them a reputation as one of the toughest defense firms in Lancaster County. They are committed to protecting the freedom and the future of every client they represent.
Their family law practice is equally vigorous. They represent clients in divorce, custody, and support cases, often handling high-conflict situations that require a firm hand. They are dedicated advocates for their clients’ rights and work tirelessly to ensure that they receive a fair deal. While they are aggressive in the courtroom, they also provide compassionate support to their clients during what is often a very emotional time. Their unique skill set and dedication to their clients earn them a spot on this list.
10. Georgelis, Larsen & Sabatino, P.C.
Rounding out our list is Georgelis, Larsen & Sabatino, P.C., a firm that has consistently been voted as one of the best in Lancaster County by local residents. While they are very well-known for their personal injury and workers’ compensation work, their family law and litigation services are also highly regarded. They are a firm that truly understands the Lancaster community and works hard to provide accessible, high-quality legal help.
Their family law department focuses on helping clients navigate the complexities of divorce and custody with a focus on clear communication and realistic expectations. They understand that legal fees can be a major concern for families, and they strive to provide value through efficient and effective representation. They are known for being approachable and easy to talk to, which helps to ease the stress of the legal process for their clients.
In criminal matters, they provide a solid defense for a variety of charges. They are committed to ensuring that every client is treated fairly by the justice system and that their rights are protected at every turn. Their strong local reputation is built on a history of successful outcomes and a genuine care for the people of Lancaster County. They are a dependable choice for anyone seeking legal help in the region.
Choosing a lawyer is a deeply personal decision. While Miller Lyden remains our top recommendation for their exceptional balance of skill and empathy, all the firms on this list provide high-quality representation. We encourage you to reach out to several of these professionals to find the one who best fits your specific needs and personality. Remember, you do not have to face the legal system alone. With the right advocate by your side, you can navigate the challenges of family and criminal law and move toward a brighter, more stable future.
In conclusion, Lancaster County is home to some truly exceptional legal talent. Whether you are dealing with a life-changing criminal charge or a sensitive family matter, the lawyers listed here represent the best the county has to offer. By choosing a firm like Miller Lyden or any of the others on this list, you are taking a vital step toward protecting your rights and ensuring that your voice is heard in the legal system. Our hope is that this guide serves as a valuable resource for our community, helping people find the support they need to overcome legal hurdles and continue their journey toward personal and community success.